Tokio Marine Highland Names Casey Santangelo President of Fine Art & Collectibles

Quick Summary

Tokio Marine Highland has appointed Casey Santangelo as President of Fine Art & Collectibles to lead its specialty underwriting division. This strategic hire, alongside Natasha Fekula as SVP of Specialty Claims, strengthens the company’s ability to manage complex risks for high-value assets and museums globally.

How does Tokio Marine Highland solve complex risk for fine art?

Tokio Marine Highland provides specialty risk management solutions tailored for high-value assets that traditional insurers often struggle to cover. By appointing Casey Santangelo, the firm enhances its technical underwriting expertise specifically for museums, galleries, and private collections. This leadership change ensures that clients receive bespoke insurance coverage that accounts for the unique volatility and valuation requirements of the fine art market.

• 18 years of experience brought by the new President to the underwriting team.
• Complex risk portfolios managed for major international galleries and museums.
• Specialized claims handling integrated directly into the fine art division.

What results has the new leadership team delivered?

The addition of Natasha Fekula as Senior Vice President of Specialty Claims ensures that high-value collection claims are handled with technical precision. Fekula’s background in reinsurance and compliance allows Tokio Marine Highland to offer a seamless end-to-end experience from policy inception to settlement. This dual-leadership approach focuses on fostering strong partnerships within the global insurance community while maintaining financial reporting rigor.

How does this move impact the collectibles market?

By recruiting top-tier talent from AXA XL, Tokio Marine Highland is positioning itself to advance market leadership in the collectibles sector. The firm leverages the Lloyd’s financial strength through its parent company, Tokio Marine Kiln, providing an A+ rated foundation for specialty property insurance. This expansion signals a significant investment in high-performing teams based in New York City to serve the Americas' most prestigious collectors.

“I’m excited to join Tokio Marine Highland to lead the Fine Art underwriting team at such an exciting time for the business,” said Santangelo. “After an incredibly rewarding chapter at AXA XL, I’m looking forward to working alongside the talented team at TMH to further strengthen our capabilities and continue providing exceptional service and expertise to our clients and partners.”

"We are at an important point in our growth journey as a company and continue to invest in the talent, expertise, and leadership that will position us for success," said Steve Prymas, CEO of Tokio Marine Highland. "Casey's deep fine art underwriting acumen and experience in building high-performing teams, combined with Natasha's exceptional track record of delivering claims solutions, will strengthen our ability to provide best-in-class service and further advance our leadership in the fine art and collectibles market."

FF NEWS TAKE:

This double-hire from AXA XL is a clear talent raid that moves the needle for Tokio Marine Highland. By securing both the underwriting and claims leads for this niche vertical, TMH isn't just filling roles; they are importing a proven ecosystem of expertise. In the high-stakes world of fine art insurance, technical reputation is everything, and this move significantly bolsters their competitive edge against larger incumbents.