Mitchell Report: EV Repair Cost Gap Hits Record Low as Claims Severity Nears Parity
By Lauren Towner · 21 August 2026
In brief: Mitchell reports that the gap in average claims severity between BEVs and ICE vehicles has reached a record low of $729 in the U.S., driven by a maturing fleet and higher total loss frequencies.
| U.S. Repair Gap | $729 |
|---|---|
| BEV OEM Part Share | 85% |
| Canada EV Sales Growth | 21% (early 2026) |

Mitchell, a leader in the development of innovative auto physical damage technology solutions, today released its latest Plugged-In: EV Collision Insights report. This quarter's report reveals that the gap in average claims severity between repairable battery electric vehicles (BEVs) and internal combustion engine (ICE) automobiles has reached its lowest level on record in both the U.S. and Canada.
With a gap of just $729 in the U.S. last quarter, average repairable severity for BEVs was $5,684 compared to $4,955 for ICE alternatives. In Canada, the gap was $1,234 CAD with BEV severity of $6,645 CAD versus $5,411 CAD for gasoline-powered automobiles. Although BEVs remain more costly to repair, Mitchell's latest data suggests that higher total loss frequency and a maturing electric vehicle fleet is bringing repair expenses across powertrain options closer to parity.
"The shrinking BEV repair cost premium is an important development for insurers and collision repairers, particularly as the electric vehicle car parc ages," said Ryan Mandell, Mitchell's vice president of strategy and market intelligence. "At the same time, ongoing trade and geopolitical uncertainty could put renewed pressure on replacement part costs and availability, with BEVs particularly exposed because of their greater reliance on OEM components."
The report also highlights markedly different regional trends in electric vehicle claims volume. While the percentage of repairable claims involving BEVs remained flat at 3% in the U.S., mild hybrid electric vehicle (MHEV) claims reached a new all-time high of 6%, up 26% year over year. In Canada, BEVs and MHEVs each accounted for more than 5% of repairable claims, setting new records and rising 12% and 28% year over year, respectively. Canadian sales of new electric automobiles also jumped 21% in the first four months of 2026 compared to the same period in 2025.
Other notable data from the report includes:
- OEM Parts Selection: BEVs continue to rely more heavily on OEM parts than ICE automobiles. On estimates for repairable vehicles, the percentage of parts dollars designated for OEM parts was 85% for BEVs versus 61% for ICE alternatives.
- Repair-Versus-Replace Decisions: Fewer parts are repaired on collision-damaged BEVs than ICE automobiles. Last quarter, 15% of parts on BEV estimates were written for repair compared to 17% for ICE vehicles.
Frequently asked questions
What is the current repair cost difference between EVs and gas cars?
In the U.S., the average repairable claims severity for BEVs is $5,684, compared to $4,955 for ICE vehicles. This results in a record-low gap of just $729. In Canada, the gap is slightly wider at $1,234 CAD, with BEV repairs averaging $6,645 CAD.
Why are EV repairs becoming more similar in price to ICE vehicles?
The narrowing gap is attributed to a maturing electric vehicle fleet and a higher frequency of total losses. As the 'car parc' ages and more data becomes available, repair processes are stabilizing, although BEVs still rely more heavily on expensive OEM parts.
How often are OEM parts used in electric vehicle repairs?
BEVs rely significantly more on Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts than gasoline vehicles. According to Mitchell, 85% of the total parts spend for BEV repairs goes toward OEM components, compared to only 61% for ICE vehicles.
About the companies
Companies in this story: Mitchell