AMA Report: Single Insurers Control 50% of Market in Nearly Half of US Metro Areas
By Effie Foxtrot · 17 November 2026
In brief: The AMA reports that 95% of U.S. commercial health insurance markets are highly concentrated, with one insurer holding at least 50% market share in 47% of metropolitan areas.
| Commercial Market Concentration | 95% of metro areas |
|---|---|
| Medicare Advantage Concentration | 97% of metro areas |
| Dominant Insurer Threshold | 50% share in 47% of metros |
| Study Scope | 385 metropolitan areas across 50 states |

The American Medical Association’s latest analysis reveals that 95% of U.S. metropolitan health insurance markets are now "highly concentrated" under federal guidelines. For carriers and insurtech vendors, this lack of competition signals a market dominated by a few incumbents, potentially stifling innovation while increasing scrutiny on vertical integration and the pricing power of dominant insurers.
What was announced
The AMA’s 2025 edition of Competition in Health Insurance: A Comprehensive Study of U.S. Markets examined 385 metropolitan areas across all 50 states and the District of Columbia. The report utilizes federal merger guidelines updated in December 2023 to measure market concentration. It found that in 47% of metropolitan areas, a single health insurer controls at least 50% of the commercial market, while 95% of all metro markets are classified as "highly concentrated." In 90% of these areas, at least one insurer held a commercial market share of 30% or greater.
Nationally, UnitedHealth Group leads the commercial sector with a 15% market share, followed by CVS (Aetna) and Elevance Health at 12% each. Cigna and Health Care Service Corp. both hold 8%, with Kaiser Permanente at 6% and Centene at 4%. However, when viewed as a collective, Blue Cross Blue Shield insurers command a dominant 42% share of the commercial market. Other notable players include Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Florida, and Blue Shield of California, each holding 2% of the national commercial market.
In the Medicare Advantage space, 97% of metro markets are highly concentrated, a slight decrease from 99% in 2017. UnitedHealth Group holds a 30% national share in Medicare Advantage and is the largest provider in 44% of all metro areas. Humana follows with a 17% national share, leading in 20% of markets. The study notes that the largest insurers have increasingly pursued vertical integration into sectors like pharmacy benefit management (PBM) following the blocked horizontal mergers of 2016, which has significant implications for physician practice independence and patient choice.
The companies involved
The American Medical Association (AMA) is the leading professional organization for physicians in the United States. According to the provided data, the organization is currently led by President Willie Underwood III. For 25 years, the AMA has conducted this comprehensive study of U.S. health insurance markets to provide a data-driven foundation for researchers, policymakers, and regulators. Its work is designed to identify specific geographies where insurance-sector mergers and acquisitions could potentially harm competition, healthcare providers, and consumers.
The organization’s reporting highlights the significant market presence of major carriers such as UnitedHealth Group, CVS (Aetna), and Elevance Health. A key focus of the AMA’s recent work is the trend toward vertical integration. The association notes that the largest health insurers have expanded their reach into other healthcare sectors, notably becoming the nation’s largest pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs). This expansion is a point of concern for the AMA, as it impacts the independence of physician practices and the breadth of choices available to patients within the healthcare system. By monitoring these shifts, the AMA aims to protect the diversity of choice for patients and the economic viability of independent medical providers within the broader insurance ecosystem.
What this means from an insurtech perspective
From an insurtech perspective, this level of market concentration presents a formidable barrier to entry for new full-stack carriers. When a handful of incumbents control up to 50% of local markets, the challenge for startups lies not just in technology, but in achieving the scale necessary for competitive provider contracting and risk pooling. This environment places immense pressure on independent brokers and MGAs, who must navigate a landscape of limited options. However, the trend toward vertical integration and the resulting regulatory scrutiny create a clear opening for insurtech vendors specializing in transparency and administrative decoupling. As the industry faces questions over the impact of PBM-insurer consolidation on loss ratios and customer trust, technology that enables more granular oversight of healthcare spending will become increasingly vital for those operating outside the dominant carrier circles.
Frequently asked questions
How concentrated are U.S. health insurance markets?
According to the AMA, 95% of commercial health insurance markets and 97% of Medicare Advantage markets are classified as highly concentrated. In nearly half of all U.S. metropolitan areas, a single insurer controls at least 50% of the commercial market share.
Which states have the least competitive health insurance markets?
The 10 states with the least competitive commercial markets are Alabama, Kentucky, Hawaii, Louisiana, Michigan, Illinois, Alaska, Indiana, Vermont, and West Virginia. Market concentration has reached 10-year peaks in states like Connecticut and South Dakota.
Who are the largest health insurers in the United States?
UnitedHealth Group is the largest individual insurer with a 15% commercial share and 30% Medicare Advantage share. However, Blue Cross Blue Shield insurers collectively lead the commercial market with a combined share of 42%.
About the companies
American Medical Association
Website · 1 story on FF News since 2026
Companies in this story: American Medical Association
People in this story: Willie Underwood III